Market Intelligence · NY / Holtsville

Holtsville, NY 11742 Housing Market

The typical home value in Holtsville, NY 11742 is $656,639, up 6.7% over the past year. The median list price sits at $562,495, with homes taking a median of 57 days on market as of September 2026.

Updated September 2026Median value$657K

The median home value in Holtsville, NY 11742 is $657K as of September 2026, up 6.7% year over year, according to Zillow ZHVI. For a read on your own home, start with a free consultation: a licensed local pro will walk you through your numbers and your options, with no obligation.

Sell without the wait

Sell your Holtsville home for cash.

A competitive, no-obligation cash offer from our institutional network. No repairs, no showings, close on your timeline. Most sellers get their cash offer within 24 hours.

Typical 11742 range

$604K to $709K

This is an automated estimate, not an appraisal. Actual value is determined by current market conditions and professional evaluation. It is provided for informational purposes only and is not an offer to buy or a promise of value.

Not sure cash is the right move? Discuss your options with a licensed local pro, free.

Asset monitoring

Track your home's value.

A free monthly briefing with your estimated value and 11742 market stats. Unsubscribe anytime.

See how a cash offer works citywide: Sell your house fast in Holtsville, NY.

12-month value trend

+6.7% over 12 months

Sep 2025$616K

Low $616KHigh $657K

Sep 2026$657K

The numbers

What is the 11742 housing market like?

As of September 2026

Typical home value

$657K

6.7%YoY

Median list price

$562K

2.3%MoM

Days on market

9.6%MoM

Homes for sale

27.3%MoM

Price cuts

6.1%

39.4%MoM

New listings

0.0%MoM

Sources · Zillow ZHVI (September 2026) / Realtor.com (September 2026) / FRED (October 2026)

The outlook

11742 housing market forecast 2027

+3.4%

Zillow forecast, 12 months to September 2027

Zillow forecasts typical home values in 11742 to rise 3.4% by September 2027.

Over the 12 months through September 2026, typical home values in 11742 rose 6.7%, per the Zillow Home Value Index.

Will home prices drop in 11742?

Zillow's forecast does not call for a drop: it expects typical home values in 11742 to rise 3.4% by September 2027, after a 6.7% rise over the past 12 months. Forecasts are not guarantees: mortgage rates, inventory, and the wider economy can move values either way.

Forecast: Zillow Home Value Forecast, published October 2026. A forecast, not a guarantee.

Free home value report

See what your 11742 home is worth.

See your estimated value and a real cash offer, side by side. No obligation, about a minute.

The comparison

How do 11742 home prices compare?

11742$656,639
Holtsville$656,639
New York$329,626
United States$285,347

Median Zillow home value (ZHVI), as of September 2026. Comparison levels are medians across every ZIP code with Zillow data (Holtsville: 1 ZIP; New York: 1,561 ZIPs; United States: 26,262 ZIPs).

Context

Holtsville is seeing steady activity, with 8 homes for sale and 8 new listings as of September 2026. The median time to sell is 57 days, a moderate pace that reflects a balanced market. Only 6.1% of listings have received a price cut, suggesting sellers are holding firm on their asking prices. The year-over-year appreciation of 6.7% shows underlying strength in property values. If you're thinking about selling, current conditions favor the patient, but waiting too long in a market this quiet could mean fewer buyer choices.

Monthly payment

Estimate your monthly payment.

Home price

Down payment20% · $131,328

Term

Rate (%)

Common questions

What people ask us.

How much is a typical home worth in Holtsville, NY 11742?

The typical home value is $656,639 as of September 2026, up 6.7% from the previous year.

How long do homes stay on the market in Holtsville?

The median days on market is 57 as of September 2026.

What is the median list price in Holtsville, NY 11742?

The median list price is $562,495 as of September 2026.

Discover

Nearby ZIP markets.

Keep reading