Market Intelligence · NY / Middletown

Middletown, NY 10940 Housing Market

The typical home value in Middletown, NY 10940 is $402,498 as of September 2026, up 3.8% over the past year. The median list price stands at $427,500, and homes are spending a median of 49 days on market.

Updated September 2026Median value$402K

The median home value in Middletown, NY 10940 is $402K as of September 2026, up 3.8% year over year, according to Zillow ZHVI. Get your own home's value and a real cash offer in about two minutes, with sources shown and no obligation.

Sell without the wait

Sell your Middletown home for cash.

A competitive, no-obligation cash offer from our institutional network. No repairs, no showings, close on your timeline. Most sellers get their cash offer within 24 hours.

Typical 10940 range

$370K to $435K

This is an automated estimate, not an appraisal. Actual value is determined by current market conditions and professional evaluation. It is provided for informational purposes only and is not an offer to buy or a promise of value.

Asset monitoring

Track your home's value.

A free monthly briefing with your estimated value and 10940 market stats. Unsubscribe anytime.

See how a cash offer works citywide: Sell your house fast in Middletown, NY.

12-month value trend

+3.8% over 12 months

Sep 2025$388K

Low $388KHigh $402K

Sep 2026$402K

The numbers

What is the 10940 housing market like?

As of September 2026

Typical home value

$402K

3.8%YoY

Median list price

$428K

0.6%MoM

Days on market

5.8%MoM

Homes for sale

133

10.8%MoM

Price cuts

17.6%

9.3%MoM

New listings

0.0%MoM

Sources · Zillow ZHVI (September 2026) / Realtor.com (September 2026) / FRED (October 2026)

Free home value report

See what your 10940 home is worth.

See your estimated value and a real cash offer, side by side. No obligation, about a minute.

The comparison

How do 10940 home prices compare?

10940$402,498
Middletown$431,644
New York$329,626
United States$285,347

Median Zillow home value (ZHVI), as of September 2026. Comparison levels are medians across every ZIP code with Zillow data (Middletown: 2 ZIPs; New York: 1,561 ZIPs; United States: 26,262 ZIPs).

Context

Middletown's 10940 market shows steady conditions as of September 2026. Typical home values sit at $402,498, up 3.8% over the past year, while the median list price of $427,500 runs higher than that typical value. There are 133 homes for sale, with 56 new listings coming on during the period. Homes take a median of 49 days to sell, and 17.6% of listings have taken a price cut. For a seller, the data points to a market that rewards realistic pricing from the start rather than testing a higher number.

Monthly payment

Estimate your monthly payment.

Home price

Down payment20% · $80,500

Term

Rate (%)

Human help

Licensed pros in 10940.

Primary seat

Jeffrey Morrissey

Lic #10401391826 NY

The Apex Collective Team at Epique Realty Experience. Precision. Results. Led by Jeffrey Morrissey, a seasoned professional with a multi-faceted background in New York real estate and public service, The Apex Collective Team at Epique Realty is defined by a high-level execution that few can match. We don’t just navigate the market; we master it. With a deep understanding of New York’s complex regulatory landscape from the Hudson Valley to the city, our team provides the sophisticated oversight r

Common questions

What people ask us.

How much is a home in 10940 worth?

The typical home value in Middletown, NY 10940 is $402,498 as of September 2026, up 3.8% over the past year. The median list price is $427,500.

How long does it take to sell a home in 10940?

Homes in 10940 spend a median of 49 days on market as of September 2026.

How competitive is the 10940 housing market?

As of September 2026, there are 133 homes for sale in 10940, with 56 new listings. About 17.6% of listings have taken a price cut.

Discover

Nearby ZIP markets.

Central Valley 10917 housing market

Keep reading